The first one, Natural, reminded me a lot of the Elf Essential Brightening Eye Color Quad in Butternut. After swatching the shadows, I found 3 colors that were almost exact dupes.
I numbered the corresponding dupes in each palette. I was most excited for # 3. This shade is an excellent dupe for Mac Woodwinked (gorgeous brown/gold shimmer). If you already have the Butternut Quad (which is only $1), I really don't see the need in getting the Geometric Palette if you wanted to save a couple bucks. You do get a couple more shades, but it is very similar. The quality of the palette is great and I love it. I, of course, had to have it lol. It's decently priced, you get a good amount of product, great pigmentation, great shadows - period.
The Smoky Palette is equally pretty.
This palette reminded me of the Elf Brightening Eye Color Quad in Drama.
Overall, I find these palettes to be excellent quality and definitely worth the price if you are in the market for some new eyeshadows. I don't think you would be disappointed in either of these, but if you wanted to save some dough maybe consider skipping the Natural Palette if you have the Butternut one. Let me know what you guys think of these! Hope you're having a great weekend!